Welcome to the ODU Unfiltered Throwback Thursday Series!
As we push through the postseason and stare down the long wait of the offseason, we’re keeping the Monarch spirit alive. Every Thursday until football season kicks off, we’re opening the vault.
We’re talking about the upsets, the milestones, and the unbelievable, unforgettable moments that define Old Dominion basketball and football. Whether you were in the stands losing your voice, pacing around your living room, or you’re a newer fan catching up on the history, this series is for you.
As Taylor Heinicke wraps up his memorable career, we think it is a great time to take a step back to where it all started.
Let’s set the scene: October 1, 2011. Foreman Field at S.B. Ballard Stadium.
Every legend has an origin story. When you look back at the chaotic, rapid rise of Old Dominion football, the timeline is distinctly split into two eras: Before Taylor, and After Taylor.
Heading into this Week 5 matchup, ODU was facing its biggest test yet. The Monarchs were hosting #20 UMass in what was ODU's first-ever CAA conference home game. The crowd was electric, and for the first half, things went perfectly. The Monarchs stormed out to a massive 25-0 lead. It felt like a coronation.
But UMass was ranked for a reason. The Minutemen mounted a furious, suffocating comeback, reeling off 26 unanswered points to take a 26-25 lead. To make matters worse, starting quarterback Thomas DeMarco went down with an injury. The momentum was entirely gone, and Foreman Field felt like the air had been completely sucked out of it. Enter the true freshman.
The Spark
When an unknown Taylor Heinicke trotted onto the field, nobody knew they were looking at the future Walter Payton Award winner. But it didn't take long for him to introduce himself.
Instead of playing conservative, terrified freshman football, Heinicke immediately began dealing. The kid wasn't just managing the game; he was actively dismantling a ranked defense.
After a blocked punt by the ODU special teams resulted in a safety to regain the lead (27-26), Heinicke took the keys to the offense and slammed the gas pedal through the floorboard. Heinicke found receiver Larry Pinkard for a beautiful 38-yard touchdown strike, proving right away that the moment wasn't too big for him.
The Deep Ball That Changed Everything
If the Pinkard touchdown was an introduction, the next drive was a statement of intent.
Midway through the fourth quarter, Heinicke dropped back, bought time, and uncorked an absolute bomb down the field to Reid Evans. The 56-yard touchdown pass wasn't just the dagger that broke the Minutemen's spirit—it was the longest pass in school history at the time.
- Final Score: ODU 48 - UMass 33
- Unanswered Points to Close the Game: 23
With Heinicke at the helm, the Monarchs rattled off 23 straight points to slam the door on UMass. It was ODU's first win over a ranked opponent, their first-ever CAA victory, and the exact moment the rest of the country realized there was a monster brewing in Norfolk.
Heinicke never relinquished the starting job after that night. He went on to rewrite the NCAA record books, throw for over 14,000 career yards, and carry that exact same underdog grit all the way to the NFL. But it all started on a crisp October night when a true freshman refused to let his team fold.
Drop your memories of Heinicke's debut in the comments!
ODU Unfiltered covers Old Dominion University athletics and institutional affairs with the honesty the official channels won't provide.